Introduction
The motivation, the objectives, the rules.
The Existence of god
Info and ideas that inform the question of the existence of a supreme being
The Nature of god
If there be a God, what kind of being would we expect God to be and why.
Preliminary stuff
There needs to be clarity on the basic terminology and concepts being applied in these discussions
Local Discussions
A place for local discussion groups to post agendas, notes and meeting times
Confused By Religion?
Some ideas presented by religion make it harder to think clearly about god.
Associated Topics
Topics which are not core to God's existence and nature
The Nature Of Humans
Did we evolve from apes? If so, how does that help us understand ourselves. Thoughts from neuroscience, psychology, biol
➧ Welcome
The Motivation
➧ Rules Of Engagement
Please read before posting
➧ Socrates
Background info
↑ Log In to contribute
1
Brian (8)

Some protocols for Socratic debate


These protocols are specific to debate - but I feel set the tone for any truth-seeking dialogue: 
 
  1. Why? is a legitimate question. Reasons should always be given when asked for.
  2. Follow the argument wherever it goes. The debaters are like rafts and the argument is the river.
  3. The river has rough and calm bits. The aim is to find the sea - not to tip your opponent from his raft.
  4. ALWAYS listen before responding. In fact to prove you have listened - restate your opposer's argument to check you have heard - before responding.
  5. The order should be a) data - what was said; b) interpret the data - what did the speaker mean; c) evaluate the argument - was the speaker right or wrong.
  6. Decide whether to use a formal or informal format (we will be using an informal format).
  7. Each debater should be given about equal time - or at least as much as he feels he needs.
  8. Try for an impartial moderator/chairman if the question is contentious.
 

… more